Who viewed my blog

Thursday, July 11, 2013

Dissenting Opinon by J. Brion - Reyes v Tan GR No. 207264, June 25, 2013

"I submit this Dissenting Opinion to express my strong reservations to the majority's outright dismissal of this most unsual case - a term I do not use lightly as shown by the reasons stated below"  -- J. Brion

Dissenting Opinion
Reyes v Tan
GR No. 207264
June 25, 2013

What is prejudicial question?

credit for abogadomo.com

Chavez v Gonzales 32 SCRA 547 - Kinds of Civil Obligations

Chavez v Gonzales 
32 SCRA 547
GR No. 27454
April 30, 1970

Rosendo O. Chaves 
-vs- 
Fructuoso Gonzales


I. Nature and effect of obligations - Article 1167 
II. Where obligation does not fix a period - Article 1197 (cannot be invoked in this case)

Facts: 
In the early part of July 1963, the plaintiff delivered to defendant typewriter repairer, a portable typewriter for  routine cleaning and servicing.